Those of you with access to the Wall Street Journal will be interested in the paper's Cranky Consumer who tested, or sought out to test, a range of VoIP services that are available in the Metro New York Area. I like the Cranky one because they reporter does a very good job of showcasing both the pluses and minuses of services reviewed in very specific terms.
While I'm not surprised about the comments made about Cablevision, Vonage or CallVantage, as the type of comments have been well documented here and elsewhere, I was also not surprised about the comments about Lingo from Primus or VoiceWing from Verizon. Both have gotten mixed reviews on the many user boards on the internet.
What I was surprised though was that the Crank didn't include Packet 8 in the test. Packet8 is publicly traded and they ride on Level3, another widely traded company. While I see value in having Cablevision and Time Warner included, the exclusion of Packet8, or their failure to be a party to the test is simply silly.